Manchester City came up short once again on the international stage. This time, it was Al Hilal who delivered the blow—knocking out Pep Guardiola’s side with a thrilling 4–3 extra-time win at Camping World Stadium in Orlando, advancing to the 2025 Club World Cup quarterfinals, where they will face Fluminense.

The result marks the end of a season without international silverware for City, and the latest setback in what’s becoming an increasingly questioned chapter in Guardiola’s legacy.

How Did the Match Unfold?

The match was an emotional rollercoaster. After 90 minutes, the game was tied 2–2, with goals from Marcos Leonardo and Malcom for Al Hilal, while Erling Haaland and Phil Foden answered for City.

In extra time, Kalidou Koulibaly headed home from a corner to give Al Hilal the lead again. Foden equalized once more, but in the 113th minute, Marcos Leonardo struck again—his second goal of the night—to seal a famous win for the Saudi side.

What Does This Mean for City and Guardiola?

The elimination is a major disappointment for Manchester City, who entered the tournament as heavy favorites after winning the 2023–24 UEFA Champions League. Despite fielding several regular starters, Guardiola’s side struggled defensively and failed to assert control against an opponent that played with belief, pace, and no fear.

The loss adds to a troubling run for City, who also lost the FA Cup Final and were knocked out in the Champions League semifinals this season.

What’s Next for Al Hilal?

With this historic victory, Al Hilal advances to the quarterfinals, where they will face Copa Libertadores champions Fluminense. Under Jorge Jesus, the Saudi club has shown it is far more than a media project—led by stars like Malcom, Rúben Neves, and Koulibaly, they’ve proven they can compete with—and defeat—Europe’s elite.

End of an Era or Temporary Setback?

This loss intensifies the conversation about whether Guardiola’s Manchester City is entering a decline. After a season filled with near-misses and big-stage failures, the narrative has shifted—from domination to doubt.

For a club accustomed to winning it all, 2025 is ending with more questions than trophies.