Harsh words after the goalless Manchester derby

Tension ran high in Pep Guardiola’s post-match press conference following Manchester City’s 0–0 draw against Manchester United at the Etihad Stadium. But it wasn’t the result that stole headlines—it was the coach’s blunt assessment of Matheus Nunes' role in the squad.

Asked why the Portuguese international wasn’t used as a central midfielder to cover for injured star Rodri, Guardiola didn’t hold back: “He could become a good right-back because of his physicality, but he’s not smart enough to play in midfield.” The comment caused a stir, not only for its bluntness but for who it targeted—a player who could be crucial in this stage of the season.

At 26, Nunes hasn’t quite secured a regular place in the starting eleven. Despite his technical abilities, Guardiola made it clear that tactical intelligence and composure are essential traits that he still lacks.

Nunes caught between praise and critique

While the criticism was sharp, Guardiola also tried to balance it with a few words of praise. “He has incredible skills and is learning a lot. He defended two or three dangerous crosses very well and has the physique to play as a full-back,” added the City boss.

The manager also reminded the press that this role for Nunes had been planned since the start of the season, just like using Nico O'Reilly as a left-back. “When I said we’d play with Matheus as a right-back, people asked, ‘What are you talking about?’ Well, this is what it is,” concluded Guardiola.

Wake-up call or tactical reality?

With the most decisive part of the season underway and Manchester City fighting on multiple fronts, Guardiola's words may serve as a challenge more than a dismissal. In his system, every position requires not only physical ability but also deep understanding of the game.

For Matheus Nunes, the message is clear: talent alone isn’t enough to command the midfield at City. Tactical awareness and decision-making are just as crucial—and now it’s up to him to show that he can grow into the player Guardiola once envisioned.